BITTER PILL TO SWALLOW
Esky Ousted Despite Connor No-Hitter
How can you give up no base hits, one walk, and commit no errors, and still lose a softball tournament game?
It happened to the Escanaba 9-10 girls on Wednesday, and only the three dozen or so Escanaba softball fans on hand in Cheboygan for the Minor Softball state quarterfinals can truly explain just how it did happen.
Sam Connor threw another excellent game for Escanaba, allowing no hits and striking out 11 batters, but lost to Southtown Bullock Creek, 1-0. The only person she walked, Shelby Bailey leading off the fourth inning, came around to score on three passed balls.
That was it. No throwing the ball around. No walking people. No line drives against. So, why did Escanaba lose? Well, if it's unbeliveable that you can lose a game while allowing just one baserunner, keep reading. It gets even crazier.
Escanaba's Alexis St. Cyr was safe on an error to start the fourth inning and went to second on the play. She advanced to third on a ground ball, then Connor put down a bunt single, with the Southtown girls choosing to let her go to first to guard against the runner coming in from third.
Here's where it gets crazy. In a first and third situation, the stolen base is a given. Connor went to second, and after a moment, was called out by the infield umpire. It was announced in the press box that Connor left first early, which is a violation, but the actual call was that Connor had rounded second base and was called out because she didn't keep going to third.
With Connor called 'out', instead of runners at second and third and one out, there were two out with a runner at third. MacKenzie Leisner struck out to end the inning.
In the sixth inning, St. Cyr worked for a one-out walk. Then on a wild pitch, she went to second, and rounded the bag again. She was called out, much to the disbelief of the Escanaba coaches, who argued long and hard.
The 2008 Little League Softball rule book, on page 70, rule 7.08, states that "if the pitcher has possession of the ball within the pitcher's circle, and is not making a play, the runners not in contact with their bases must immediately attempt to advance, or to return to base."
In both cases, the Escanaba runner went back to the bag. But this umpire, who is from southern Lower Michigan, said that any runner who rounds the bag is automatically out, unless the runner continues to the next bag. Not true, according to the above-noted rule.
In addition, the Escanaba coaches said the umpires told them at the tournament's opening meeting that the girl rounding a bag would be given a couple of seconds to go back to the bag.
Kelsey Forvilly struck out to end the game, and Escanaba manager Deb Leisner continued to argue the call.
"It's very tough," Leisner said, choking back tears. "I feel like, you know, the girls have given it their all. We feel that the umpires took it away from them."
The consensus amongst several coaches gathered, and even some of Southtown's supporters were that the "rounding the bag" call was not a good one, particularly at the 9-10 level, and in a 1-0 game.
Leisner tried to protest the call to Central Regional Headquarters in Indianapolis, but was told that it was not a call that could be protested.
Escanaba had only three hits off of Bailey, who pitched all six innings for the win, striking out five and walking one. Forvilly had a hit in the first inning, Brittany Douglas had a lead-off single in the fifth, and Connor had that bunt.
"We had great community support, a lot of tremendous parent support," Leisner said. "The girls have worked hard. I'm extremely proud of everybody. I hope all the fans are proud of them too."
Connor was the tough-luck loser, allowing no hits, one walk, 11 strikeouts.
"She's been great all year long," Leisner said. "She really digs deep, she's a great pitcher. Sam did a great job today, and it was also a 12-man team effort."
Wednesday's Quarterfinals Southtown Bullock Creek 1, ESCANABA 0 Parchment 11, Mattawan 1 Cheboygan vs Western Grand Rapids, 6 p.m. St. Clair vs Tecumseh, 6 p.m.
Thursday's Semifinals Bullock Creek vs Cheb/WGR winner, 4 p.m. Parchment vs StC/Tecum winner, 6:30 p.m. |